Why Private Real Estate Is a Smarter First Investment Than REITs or Mutual Funds

The First Investment Decision: Direction Over Convenience

When someone decides to make their first investment, the question is rarely "What will create generational wealth?" It’s usually "What’s easy to start with?"

That’s why so many first-time investors are nudged toward mutual funds or REITs. They’re simple to access, and they feel familiar. But ease doesn’t always equal effectiveness. And if your goal is to build meaningful, lasting wealth, you’ll want to understand what private real estate can offer that these public vehicles cannot.

Public vs. Private: Know the Playing Field

REITs and mutual funds trade on public markets. That means their prices are constantly reacting to investor sentiment, market noise, and broader volatility—even when the underlying assets are stable. In contrast, private real estate investments are insulated from the daily fluctuations of Wall Street. They’re priced based on fundamentals, not on emotion.

Here’s what that really means: With private real estate, your investment isn’t tanking just because someone panicked in another sector. The performance is driven by the income and appreciation of the actual asset, not by market speculation.

Control Isn’t Just Comfort—It’s a Strategy

With private real estate, investors can often choose specific markets, asset types, and investment theses. You’re not just buying a slice of a pre-packaged fund; you’re making decisions that align with your beliefs, your research, and your risk appetite.

Contrast this with mutual funds, where you’re locked into someone else’s vision of diversification. Or REITs, where you’re exposed to leverage and liquidity pressure that can force bad decisions at the fund level. In private real estate, there’s room for discretion—and discretion creates opportunity.

Risk Isn’t What You Think It Is

One of the biggest misconceptions is that private investments are inherently riskier than public ones. That may be true if you’re speculating wildly or have no access to institutional-quality deals. But if you invest through a disciplined platform like Infinity⁹, with its rigorous Building Capital Framework, the risks become far more measured—and often more manageable—than in public markets.

A public REIT might hold dozens of assets, but it’s also exposed to daily liquidity demands. That creates risk. Private real estate doesn’t have that problem. It can ride through cycles. It can prioritize long-term value creation. And it doesn’t have to react to quarterly earnings pressure.

Cash Flow Matters More Than Charts

Mutual funds and REITs are often sold with a chart. Look at this line. It’s going up. But that line doesn’t pay your bills.

Private real estate generates real cash flow—monthly or quarterly distributions that you can use, reinvest, or allocate elsewhere. That’s not just appealing. It’s powerful. Because compounding works best with consistent inputs, and few vehicles deliver those as reliably as well-structured private real estate.

The Tax Advantage Nobody Talks About

Ask a tax advisor which investment structure offers better tax efficiency, and private real estate will almost always come out ahead. Depreciation, cost segregation, and the ability to defer gains via 1031 exchanges are powerful tools.

With REITs, you get taxed on dividends as ordinary income. With mutual funds, you can get hit with capital gains you didn’t even realize were happening. But with private deals, you have a level of control and efficiency that’s hard to match.

You’re Not Late. You’re Early.

One of the biggest myths is that you need millions to participate in private real estate. That might have been true a decade ago. Today, platforms like Infinity⁹ give qualified investors access to institutional-grade opportunities—without needing to be an institution.

And starting early isn’t just about time in the market. It’s about learning. Participating in your first deal gives you insight you won’t get from owning a sliver of a mutual fund. It builds knowledge, context, and intuition. And it sets the stage for smarter, more strategic decisions down the line.

There Are No Bad Markets—Just Bad Strategies

At Infinity⁹, we don’t believe in waiting for perfect timing. We believe in structuring investments intelligently for the conditions we’re in. That’s the value of private real estate: the ability to adjust, adapt, and grow, regardless of headlines.

Mutual funds and REITs have to react. Private real estate can act. That single difference can define the shape of your wealth over time.

‍