How to Evaluate a Real Estate Operator Like a Family Office Would

Why the Operator is the Investment

Let’s start with a truth that seasoned investors know instinctively: you're not investing in real estate. You're investing in the people managing that real estate.

For family offices, private capital funds, and institutional allocators, due diligence starts with the operator. Before a deal’s numbers are even discussed, they want to know who is behind the project, how they operate, and what their track record really says. This is where most individual investors fall short. They focus on the property—its location, its cash flow, its projected IRR—and overlook the most critical variable: human execution.

At Infinity⁹, we believe that execution risk is often the greatest risk in private investments. There are no bad markets, just bad strategies—and behind every strategy is a team. Evaluating that team properly is one of the most valuable skills you can develop.

Here’s how the pros do it.

1. Look for Operational Maturity, Not Just Experience

A common mistake: assuming that "20 years of experience" automatically means competence. What family offices care more about is operational maturity. That means:

• Can they manage complexity?
• Have they survived a downturn—or just grown in a bull market?
• Do they have internal systems, teams, and discipline—or are they still operating like a two-person startup?

A seasoned operator who has only worked in rising markets may be less trustworthy than a newer team that has already proven they can navigate a crisis.

Ask: How do they operate during stress?

2. Ask for More Than the Highlight Reel

Good operators are proud of their track records. Great ones are transparent about their failures.

Sophisticated investors don’t just ask for the wins. They dig into the losses. What went wrong? What changed in their underwriting assumptions? What did they learn?

If a sponsor only shows you deals that hit their pro forma, you’re not seeing the full picture. No serious investor expects perfection. What they expect is accountability, reflection, and evolution.

At Infinity⁹, we look for operators who can articulate not only what they did right—but how they’ve adapted when things didn’t go to plan.

3. Underwriting Discipline: Can They Walk Away from a Good Deal?

In bull markets, capital is easy to deploy. The real discipline is in saying no.

Family offices often ask: Tell me about the last three deals you passed on.

The answer reveals a lot:

• Is their strategy truly selective, or are they chasing yield?
• Do they have an investment framework they follow, or do they adapt it depending on the capital they need to raise?
• Are they willing to walk away from a flashy project that doesn’t align with their principles?

This is where you separate promoters from operators.

4. Alignment of Interests: Do They Have Real Skin in the Game?

Private investors are especially vulnerable to asymmetrical risk. Operators make fees no matter what. Investors take the hit if the deal underperforms.

Family offices scrutinize the structure:

• How much of the GP’s own capital is at risk?
• Are fees front-loaded, or does the operator make most of their profit from performance?
• Is there a preferred return or a hurdle?

You want an operator who’s not just incentivized to perform—but who feels it personally if they don’t.

At Infinity⁹, we aim for alignment structures that reward real success—not just asset accumulation.

5. Transparency and Reporting: What Will You Know and When?

The best operators communicate like professionals, not salespeople. Sophisticated investors look for:

• Standardized reporting (quarterly financials, KPIs, leasing status)
• Clear communication during setbacks
• A dedicated investor relations contact—not just the deal sponsor emailing from their iPhone

When you ask questions, do they get defensive—or informative?

At the family office level, if the operator doesn't treat investor communication as a core part of their business, it's a red flag.

6. Operational Edge: What’s Their Secret Sauce?

Ask them: What do you do better than anyone else?

Real estate is competitive. Every city has hundreds of developers. Why does this team consistently win deals, lease faster, manage tighter?

Sophisticated investors are looking for a clear edge—an underwriting insight, a network advantage, or a cost control strategy—that gives this operator a reason to outperform.

This is part of what we call Building Capital Framework at Infinity⁹: assessing not just the asset, but the underlying system that produces consistent outcomes.

7. References That Go Beyond the Surface

Don’t just ask for investor references. Ask for:

• Lenders they've worked with
• Contractors and vendors they’ve paid
• Tenants they’ve served
• Former employees

You’ll learn more about a team’s character from how they treat people when no one’s watching than from what’s in their pitch deck.

The Infinity⁹ Perspective

We evaluate operators the way we would if it were our family’s capital—because in many cases, it is.

We believe that institutional-quality real estate opportunities require institutional-level scrutiny. And we invest with people, not just properties. Our approach is designed for durability, not hype.

That’s how you build long-term capital frameworks.

And that’s why evaluating an operator should never be an afterthought. It’s the investment.

‍