Should You Buy a Rental Property in 2025? What First-Time Investors Need to Know

What’s Different About Buying Rental Property in 2025?

The U.S. housing market isn’t what it was five years ago—or even one year ago. Median home prices are up, mortgage rates remain elevated, and regional markets are behaving very differently from each other.

While real estate headlines often highlight volatility or cooling trends, that doesn’t mean opportunity has disappeared. In fact, strategic private investments in income-producing real estate may offer more risk-adjusted value now than during the boom years.

Key Market Shifts to Know:

• Interest Rates Remain High
  As of mid-2025, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate hovers around 6.8%. This reduces affordability for buyers—but also creates higher demand in the rental market as many would-be homeowners delay buying.
• Rent Growth Is Slowing—but Stabilizing
  After explosive rent increases in 2021–2023, many U.S. cities are seeing rent growth flatten. However, certain regions—particularly in the Southeast and Mountain West—continue to post strong rental demand due to population growth and job migration.
• Local Markets Matter More Than Ever
  In 2025, “real estate is local” is more than just a cliché. National averages are misleading. Some cities are overbuilt and softening, while others are undersupplied and rising. Understanding where to invest is as important as what to invest in.

The First-Time Investor’s Dilemma: Buy a Property or Invest in a Private Deal?

Owning a rental home seems straightforward: buy a house, rent it out, collect monthly income. But first-time investors often underestimate what it actually takes to manage a rental property effectively—and profitably.

Hidden Challenges in Owning a Rental:

• Unexpected maintenance costs (roof repairs, HVAC, plumbing)
• Vacancies and tenant turnover
• Local landlord-tenant laws and compliance requirements
• Property management fees (or the time cost if self-managed)
• Illiquidity when you want or need to sell

A rental property is a business. And in 2025, running that business profitably requires strong capital discipline, an understanding of macro trends, and operational know-how.

An Alternative Path: Private Real Estate Investments

Through firms like Infinity⁹, investors can gain exposure to income-producing real estate without the hassle of owning individual rental units. These private investments often target larger, institutional-quality properties—think multi-family buildings, logistics centers, or senior living assets—offering built-in management, diversified tenant bases, and sophisticated risk controls.

Our take: For most first-time investors, especially in today’s market, a well-vetted private real estate deal is likely to be a stronger, more passive way to build wealth than buying a single-family rental on your own.

What to Look for in 2025: High-Quality Rental Investments

If you’re still considering buying your first rental property, these are the key traits to look for in a viable opportunity:

1. Location with Population and Job Growth

Avoid stagnant or shrinking towns. Focus on metros with strong in-migration, new business development, and favorable landlord laws. Think Charlotte, Tampa, Boise, or parts of Texas.

2. Positive Cash Flow from Day One

Don’t speculate on appreciation. Make sure your projected rental income covers all costs—including mortgage, taxes, insurance, and maintenance—with a cushion left over.

3. Professional Property Management

Even for a single property, hiring an experienced property manager can save you thousands in mistakes. Just factor it into your numbers upfront.

4. Exit Flexibility

What’s your plan if the market shifts in five years? Can you refinance? Sell to another investor? Rent to a different segment? Every good deal needs an exit strategy.

2025 May Not Be a Bargain Year—but It Can Be a Smart Year

Some people are waiting for prices to crash. That’s not happening. Instead, we’re seeing a market that rewards strategicentry, not impulsive buying.

At Infinity⁹, we don’t believe in “timing the market.” We believe in building a capital framework that works in any market. There are no bad markets, just bad strategies. And in 2025, the strategy that often wins is one that prioritizes passive, professionally managed income over DIY investing.

Bottom Line: Should You Buy a Rental Property in 2025?

If you have deep knowledge of a local market, access to financing, and are ready to treat your property like a business—you might find a worthwhile opportunity.

But for most first-time investors, especially those looking for strong risk-adjusted returns with less hassle, private real estate investing offers a more flexible, scalable, and often more profitable path.

As we always say: your money doesn’t need a visa. And your portfolio doesn’t need a mortgage if the right opportunity already includes income, diversification, and expert management.

‍